QIT#8 I’m sick and tired of this infernal blog debate
May 13, 2009 Author: Joanna | Filed under: UncategorizedThis is something I’ll put more thought into tomorrow, but I needed to post this in order to sleep!
It was prompted by a panel discussion at the Journalism Leaders Forum today where, once again, the “blogs are rubbish and can’t be trusted” mantra was trotted out by some of the panel members.
Why? Why are we still even having this debate?
Why is it that when you talk about blogs to some journalists, the images that pop into their heads are of the celebrity-obsessed, the political rumour-mongers or the batshit insane?
Why don’t they think about the first hand accounts of conflict, the well-respected tech news sites, the local community information or those producing focused industry analysis?
(Oh, and as for that “citizen journalism“… well who needs that?)
Recent Comments
Recent Posts
Blogroll
- Adam Tinworth
- Alison Gow
- Andy Dickinson
- Birmingham Social Media Cafe
- Buzzmachine
- Chris Unitt
- Created in Birmingham
- Dave Briggs
- Dave Lee
- Dilyan Damyanov
- Editors’ Weblog
- Ewan Spence
- Glyn Mottershead
- Jon Bounds
- Jonathan Walker
- Journalism Technology
- Justin Williams
- Kevin Matthews
- Kristine Lowe
- Louise Bolotin
- Mark Comerford
- Martin Stabe
- Newspaper Death Watch
- Nick Booth
- Online Journalism Blog
- Pete Ashton
- Sarah Hartley
- Strange Attractor
- The Wire
- Tom Scotney
Archives
Tags
About
What others have said
Most Popular
- New Job (69)
- Quick, incoherent thought #2: Why most news doesn't need journos (45)
- The Birmingham Mail's Gareth Barry letter: why so late on the web? (39)
- "The Collaborator"? Naming Newspapers 2.0 (32)
- Online Protests - why do they make me uneasy? (31)
- Journalists don't know their own business (26)
- Anyone want to help design the Birmingham Post website? (20)
- Could The Post website use Flickr? (20)
- Interaction on business news websites (20)
- Regional newspapers do not produce good journalists... (19)
Recent Comments
- BBC cuts, my 2p | Pete Ashton: [...] from a Press Gazette
- Story Review » Blog Archive » How to report the news: [...] Joanna Geary Tags:
- Blogging on «: [...] Post’s social presence online and this
- Mark W Schaefer: Thanks for including my blog
- Mark Hanson: After series 5 of The
- Kit Kats and Collaboration – Joanna Geary « Horseradish on Toast: [...] her ass” and got
- Joanna: Ach! You're such cheats!
Both - Nick Booth: Like Paul I'd choose both,
- news:rewired, 14 January 2010, City University London » Blog Archive » #newsrw: Student online enthusiasts will probably end up in the mainstream, says @timesjoanna: [...] students seeking employment at
- the red postman: It depends on whether you
9 Responses for "QIT#8 I’m sick and tired of this infernal blog debate"
You were excellent and had a number of salient, important and thoughtful points. That some of the participants were still living in the past is one of the reasons the industry is in crisis. That there are thoughtful, passionate journalists like you is one of the possible reasons to look optimistically to a future for journalism.
As with all forms of media, from the first printing press to twitter, there are those who just don’t get it, those who do, those who use it well, and those who don’t.
Blogging is a relatively new medium that has its place, but that place has to be fought for and proven. Twas ever thus.
I believe it can be a force for good, and your eloquent support is key to its survival.
I had “blogs are all piffle” on a training course I was teaching on last week.
I’ve taken to carrying a copy of Doctor Who Adventures to such trainings, so I can then go on to define what a magazine is by flicking through it: “So, magazines have free gifts on the cover, are based on TV shows, and have lots and lots of photos from the TV show inside, as well as quizzes, puzzles and posters”.
That normally makes the point…
I’m filing away the epithet “batshit insane” for future use. Thanks.
[...] QIT#8 I’m sick and tired of this infernal blog debate [...]
links for 2009-05-14…
QIT#8 I’m sick and tired of this infernal blog debate | Joanna Geary Can we all collectively get over this whole “blogs are rubbish” thing now, please (tags: journalism journalists blogging) Lifehacker – Use a Sub-Savings Account for Unexpected……
[...] felt sorry for them but it made me kind of mad. And then Chris Unitt posted the above video of Joanna Geary arguing against some quite astounding statements, and I got even [...]
[...] Caine and Geoff Caine (who began as patients set up a blog then became surgeons). Abby Corfan, Joanna Geary and Nicky Getgood have helped alongside Julia Gilbert (also a passionate organisation helper), [...]
[...] Caine and Geoff Caine (who began as patients, set up a blog then became surgeons). Abby Corfan, Joanna Geary and Nicky Getgood have helped alongside Julia Gilbert (also a passionate organisational helper), [...]
Leave a reply